Shortlist.

Tire shops · Tallahassee, FL

The 4 tire shops in Tallahassee worth calling first

We compared 37. These 4 are where we would start. One clear reason each.

37tire shops compared
33close, but not selected
4on the shortlist

Updated No sponsored places in this listHow selection works

01 30-second comparison

The shortlist at a glance

4 tire shops in Tallahassee, ranked. Ratings and review counts from public sources, checked October 31, 2026.
RankBusinessBest forRatingExperienceAction
No. 1: Mavis Tires & BrakesTallahassee Most reviewed 4.8 (2701) – Quote
No. 2: Mavis Tires & BrakesTallahassee – 4.8 (1638) – Quote
No. 3: Jim Wells Tire CenterTallahassee – 4.9 (114 (2021)) – Quote
No. 4: Proctor SubaruTallahassee Best overall 4.9 (3575) – Quote
02 The first calls

The 3 to call first

03 More

More Tire shops in Tallahassee

Close, but not on this list

Reasonable calls. Just not our first.

  • Mavis Tires & Brakes4.8 from 2142 reviews · Tallahassee.
  • Proctor Acura4.8 from 1554 reviews · Tallahassee.
  • Discount Tire4.5 from 1016 reviews · Tallahassee.
  • Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires4.5 from 1271 reviews · Tallahassee.
  • Peter Boulware Toyota Service Center4.5 from 1152 reviews · Tallahassee.
  • Tire Choice Auto Service Centers4.7 from 208 (2021) reviews · Tallahassee.
04 Quotes

Ask the shortlist for a quote

Send my request to
Choose more businesses

Only the businesses you tick receive it. A fee we may earn never affects the list. How we make money.

05 Before you hire

What to ask before hiring

  1. Can I see your license and insurance?Look the license up on the state’s own portal. It takes two minutes.
  2. Who pulls the permit, and is it in the price?It should be the business, and it should be in writing.
  3. What is the payment schedule?Payments should follow the work. Be wary of large deposits up front.
  4. Which parts of the job do you subcontract?Most do some. You want to know who will be at your home.
  5. What does the warranty cover, and for how long?Labour, materials and equipment often have different terms.
  6. Can I talk to two customers from the last year?Recent ones, not the showcase project from years ago.

The full guide for Tallahassee

06 Local facts

Tallahassee in numbers

The public numbers behind this list: the local market and the rules every job here has to meet.

$294,400

Median home value (Median value of owner-occupied homes (ACS table B25077).)

2020–2024 · U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates

53.3%

Homes built before 1990 (51,828 of 97,245 housing units were built in 1989 or earlier (ACS table B25034, year structure built).)

2020–2024 · U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates

85,311

Households in Tallahassee (Occupied housing units (one household per occupied home), ACS table B25003.)

2020–2024 · U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates

June 1 to November 30

Atlantic hurricane season (An average season (1991–2020) has 14 named storms, 7 hurricanes and 3 major hurricanes.)

1991–2020 climate period · NOAA National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Climatology

1988

Median year homes were built (Half of all housing units were built before this year (ACS table B25035).)

2020–2024 · U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates

40.6%

Owner-occupied homes (34,661 of 85,311 occupied homes are lived in by their owners (ACS table B25003).)

2020–2024 · U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates

Figures from public sources. Figures tagged “Sample figure” show what the live data feed will fill in; they are not real counts.

07 FAQ

Questions people ask

How did the editors choose these tire shops in Tallahassee?

Editors shortlist businesses with strong ratings and enough reviews, check their records, and choose the final picks against the published criteria. We compared 37 tire shops for Tallahassee. Paid placements never change the order.

Which of these tire shops in Tallahassee has the best reviews?

Proctor Subaru has a 4.9 rating from 3575 public reviews, the highest on this page.

Are these tire shops licensed?

We are still checking licenses for this list. Before you hire, look the business up on the state licensing board's website.

How many quotes should I get for tire shops in Tallahassee?

Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request.

08 More shortlists

Related shortlists and nearby places

Other services in Tallahassee

Tire shops nearby

All Tallahassee shortlists

09 Method & corrections

Method, corrections and money

Method

Rating, review and record checks, then a clear reason for every pick. Full method.

Corrections

Spot something wrong? We check it against a second source and log every change. Send a correction.

Money

Businesses can pay for an enhanced profile or for quote requests. That never buys a place here. How we make money. Own a business listed here? Claim your free profile.